A ¥7,700/month hot spring usage charge pushes up the real cost
Royal Vanbelle Atami Izu-Taga is a 50-unit building built in 1992, standing on high ground in Shimotaga, about 2.3 km (4 min by car) from Izu-Taga Station. It has a hot spring communal bath, a sauna, a party room, and a roof garden, and is managed under a full commission to Tokyu Community (resident). What cannot be overlooked in the holding cost is the hot spring usage charge. For the unit on the market (5th-floor studio 44.5㎡, ¥5.0M), on top of the management fee of ¥24,300 and repair reserve fund of ¥6,300 (¥30,600/month) is a separately-charged hot spring usage fee of ¥7,700 every month. The real monthly amount including the hot spring charge is ¥38,300, incurred at a fixed rate whether or not you use the communal bath. Because the price is a cheap ¥5.0M, the holding-cost ratio is 7.3% from management fee and reserve alone, and rises into the 9% range including the hot spring charge — a typical case where a cheaper property shows a higher holding-cost ratio.
The reserve is below the benchmark — even with a rising index, the management side needs confirmation
The market side is firm: Mansion Navi shows about a 30.8% rise over the most recent 3 years. The listing's ¥371,000/tsubo is also within a consistent range with Mansion Review's AI-estimated ¥320,000/tsubo, a building with small price divergence. On the other hand, the repair reserve fund is about ¥142/㎡, below MLIT's benchmark (¥190–325/㎡). Because there is no backing for the reserve balance in public information, whether the thin unit price is a result of accumulation cannot be distinguished from outside. The fixed asset tax is about ¥80,200 (FY Reiwa 7). The villa tax is under investigation on the property page, but as Shimotaga is within Atami City and subject to the villa tax, a non-resident use should anticipate a separate burden.
The editorial team's assessment
The verdict is stable. The alignment of the index with the actual market, an uptrending market rate, and resident professional management are positive materials. However, the keys to the judgment are the reserve and the hot spring charge, and the ¥7,700/month hot spring usage charge becomes a fixed cost not to be ignored in long-term holding. Confirming the reserve balance, long-term repair plan, and the actual villa tax amount on paper, and evaluating the price on an annual holding cost that includes the hot spring charge, is the crux for this building.
