A building where index sources split — which market rate to trust
Seaside Villa Minami-Atami is a 78-unit building built in 1993 (built by Kumagai Gumi), standing on the sea side of Kamitaga, about 1.2 km from Izu-Taga Station. It has a resort spec with a hot spring communal bath (with sauna, 24 hours) and a summer outdoor pool, but it is a building where the price is hard to read. The single listing, a 1st-floor studio 65.4㎡ with a 15.88㎡ balcony at ¥24.8M (¥1,254,000/tsubo), matches Mansion Review's AI-estimated ¥1,250,000/tsubo. Yet Mansion Market's market band is ¥16.1M–16.9M, and against that the same per-tsubo price looks quite high. Furthermore, Mansion Market has recorded about a 15.7% decline over the most recent year. The conclusion changing depending on the index source is a typical example of general-purpose market rates breaking down for resort condominiums.
The reserve is within the benchmark, and the holding-cost ratio is light
The cost side is sound. The unit on the market has a management fee of ¥38,600 and repair reserve fund of ¥15,054 (¥53,654/month), with a water charge of ¥4,378 per two months (about ¥2,189/month). The repair reserve fund is about ¥230/㎡, within MLIT's benchmark (¥190–325/㎡) — neither too thin nor thick, on the thicker side. Because the price is a higher ¥24.8M, the share of the annual management fee and reserve in the price (holding-cost ratio) becomes a light 2.6%. The fixed asset tax and villa tax are under investigation on the property page and not yet obtained, but Kamitaga is within Atami City and subject to the villa tax (tax on ownership of villas, etc.). For non-resident use, you need to estimate on the premise of a separate villa tax of ¥650 per ㎡ of total floor area per year.
The editorial team's assessment
The verdict is watch closely. The soundness of the equipment and reserve is commendable, but with the divergence between index sources and a recent decline record, the reasonableness of the price cannot be fixed from a single listing alone. The specialness that the listing's ¥24.8M is a 1st-floor unit with a large terrace should also be discounted; it is a building where you want to verify the price from both the transaction cases of multiple portals and the annual holding cost including the villa tax.
