¥148,000/tsubo and ¥460,000/tsubo in the same building—the price of floor level and a Mt. Fuji view
The 4 units for sale at Recess Yamanakako range more than fourfold, from ¥2.8M to ¥12.3M. The low-floor ¥2.8M (62.55㎡) and ¥3.2M (70.85㎡) are just under ¥150,000/tsubo, 30% below the reference index; meanwhile the 6th-floor 88.4㎡, with a view of Mt. Fuji and Lake Yamanaka from the living room, is ¥12.3M at ¥460,000/tsubo—more than twice the index. In this building, standing on high ground at about 1,000m elevation, the view from the 4th floor and above explains most of the price. If you seek a view, paying a commensurate price for the scarcity of the upper floors is a defensible judgment, but if you are considering a low floor, the fact that "a view-less unit in the same building can be bought for ¥150,000/tsubo" becomes the starting point of negotiation.
The lower-priced the unit, the heavier the upkeep—the holding-cost ratio reaches over 14%
For the 88.4㎡ unit, the actual example is a management fee of ¥41,300 + repair reserve fund of ¥5,750 = ¥47,050/month (plus a Wi-Fi usage fee of ¥1,100). Adding fixed asset tax of about ¥85,600 (FY Reiwa 8) and village and prefectural resident tax of ¥4,500, the annual fixed cost is about ¥650,000. For the ¥12.3M upper floor, the holding-cost ratio is 4.6% per year, but for the ¥2.8M low floor the combined monthly amount of ¥33,270 reaches 14.3% per year—a few years of upkeep equals the property price. The repair reserve fund is about ¥65/㎡ per month, a level far below the MLIT benchmark, a structure where costs lean onto the management-fee side.
Repairs are being handled—works records of 2010, 2018 and 2023
This building's positive material is its record of implementing repairs. It carried out exterior-wall renovation in 2010, exterior-wall and entrance repairs in 2018, and parking-lot concrete paving and ironwork painting in 2023; it can be confirmed that works are regularly handled under Tokyu Community's full-outsourcing, day-shift management. The sauna-equipped communal bath (heated water) is operated on a limited basis—Fridays, Saturdays, Sundays, holidays and specific periods—which reads as a realistic choice to hold down the facility-maintenance burden for a scale of 64 units. Since the low reserve unit rate remains a concern, confirming the reserve balance and the next repair plan is essential.
The editorial team's assessment
The verdict is "watch closely." While as a building there is little concern about the repair record and management structure, three points are to be confirmed: (1) the price polarization between units is large, making the market index hard to use for judgment; (2) low-priced units have a heavy holding-cost ratio of over 14% per year; and (3) the validity of the ¥65/㎡ reserve unit rate cannot be judged without seeing the reserve balance. Since there is no rental listing history and an exit via renting out is hard to expect, this is a building for people with many days of self-use.
